Quick answer
The Consumer Review Fairness Act makes it illegal to use a form contract, such as your online terms of sale, that bars or restricts the ability of a person who is a party to that contract to review a company’s products, services, or conduct, that imposes a penalty or fee against someone who gives a review, or that requires people to give up their intellectual property rights in the content of their reviews. It is enforced by the Federal Trade Commission and the state Attorneys General. Review gating, where you ask only happy customers for reviews, is a separate problem: Google bans it outright, and the FTC says this practice could violate the FTC Act.
Nation, an AI store builder, publishes this page. It is not in the fee comparison. See where Nation fits.
What the Consumer Review Fairness Act bans
The Consumer Review Fairness Act (CRFA) is a federal law, Pub. L. 114–258, signed on Dec. 14, 2016. It sits in the US Code at §45b. Consumer review protection. It deals with clauses in a business's standard terms that restrict, penalize or claim ownership of customer reviews.
The law targets form contracts. A form contract is a contract with standard terms used to sell or lease goods or services and imposed on an individual without a meaningful opportunity for such individual to negotiate the standardized terms. For an online shop, that means the terms of sale a buyer accepts at checkout, the fine print on an order form and any click-through agreement. The FTC's own example is a business that includes a provision in its terms and conditions that prohibits or punishes negative reviews by customers.
The FTC summarizes the ban in three parts. A business may not use a contract provision that:
- bars or restricts the ability of a person who is a party to that contract to review a company’s products, services, or conduct (a gag clause or non-disparagement clause);
- imposes a penalty or fee against someone who gives a review (a fine for a bad review);
- requires people to give up their intellectual property rights in the content of their reviews (a clause that takes copyright in what the buyer writes or photographs).
A clause like this is void from the inception of such contract, so it cannot be enforced against the buyer. Separately, it is unlawful for a person to offer a form contract containing a provision described as void. The second rule matters for small sellers: having the clause in your terms breaks the law even if you never use it.
This page is general information, not legal advice. State laws on contracts and reviews vary, so check your own state's rules or ask a lawyer before you change your terms.
What the CRFA bans and what you may still do
The law protects honest reviews, but it does not force a business to host every comment. The table sets the banned clauses next to what a business may still do, as the statute and the FTC's guidance describe it.
The "clearly false" exception is narrow. The FTC warns that it’s unlikely that a consumer’s assessment or opinion with which you disagree meets the “clearly false or misleading” standard. Example: a one-star review that calls a product overpriced is an opinion, so it is unlikely to meet that standard.
What counts as a review under the law
The CRFA reaches more than star ratings. The FTC lists online reviews, social media posts, uploaded photos, videos, and says the law also covers consumer evaluations of a company’s customer service. The statute's definition of a pictorial review includes pictures, photographs, video, illustrations, and symbols. For example, a buyer who posts an unboxing video, a photo of a damaged parcel or a complaint about slow replies is protected in the same way as one who writes a paragraph.
Who enforces the CRFA and what happens to violators
Congress gave enforcement to the Federal Trade Commission and the state Attorneys General. A violation is treated the same as violating an FTC rule defining an unfair or deceptive act or practice, which the FTC says means a business could face financial penalties, as well as a federal court order. A state attorney general can also bring a civil action on behalf of the residents of the State.
Because a banned clause is void from the inception of such contract, it has no legal effect on the buyer, whether or not anyone enforces the law against the business.
What review gating is and why it breaks the rules
Review gating means screening customers before you ask for a public review. Example: a store sends every buyer a short survey first. Buyers who pick four or five stars get a link to Google or the product page. Buyers who pick fewer stars get a private feedback form instead, so their opinion never reaches the public.
Review gating usually involves no clause in the buyer's contract, so the rules that apply to it come from Google's review policy and the FTC.
- Google's policy for reviews on Maps and Business Profiles says merchants may not Discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers. Google also bans merchants who Offer incentives – such as payment, discounts, free goods and/or services - in exchange for posting any review, and says Fake engagement is not allowed and will be removed.
- The FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465, took effect on October 21, 2024. Asked whether a business can request reviews only from customers it thinks are happy, the FTC said the rule does not contain a specific prohibition against such conduct, but this practice could violate the FTC Act.
- The same rule bars a business from claiming that the reviews on its review page represent most or all the reviews submitted to the website or platform when reviews are being suppressed based on rating or negative sentiment. A store that hides low ratings while presenting its review section as complete would run into this part of the rule.
The safe pattern is to ask every buyer in the same way, with the same message, and to send everyone to the same public review link.
How the CRFA fits with the FTC fake reviews rule
The CRFA deals with contracts. The FTC's newer rule, announced on August 14, 2024, deals with how reviews are bought, written, displayed and suppressed. The rule authorizes civil penalties for knowing violations. A few parts of it sit close to the CRFA:
- Threats: the rule bans using an unfounded or groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation, or a public false accusation to stop a review or get one removed.
- Paying for a sentiment: the rule bans compensation or other incentives conditioned on the writing of consumer reviews expressing a particular sentiment, either positive or negative. The FTC's answer on paying incentives for five-star reviews on third-party review platforms, even with a disclosure, is: That conduct would violate Section 465.4.
- Neutral incentives: the rule does not prohibit giving incentives for reviews, as long as there isn’t an express or implied requirement that the review be positive. Google's policy is stricter for Maps: merchants may not Offer incentives – such as payment, discounts, free goods and/or services - in exchange for posting any review.
- Sorting: the FTC says Organizing reviews is not suppressing reviews under the rule, but organizing reviews in a way that makes it difficult for consumers to know about or find negative reviews could be an unfair or deceptive act.
Withholding a review on your own site is allowed when you use criteria for withholding reviews that are applied equally to all reviews submitted without regard to sentiment, or when The seller reasonably believes the review is fake.
How to check your store against the CRFA
The FTC's compliance advice for the CRFA comes down to the first two steps. The last two cover how you ask for and moderate reviews under Google's policy and the FTC's rule.
Find every form contract
Review your form contracts, including online terms and conditions. Include checkout terms, custom-order forms, wholesale order forms for individual buyers, and any template you copied from another store or a theme.
Delete review restrictions
Remove any provision that restricts people from sharing their honest reviews, penalizes those who do, or claims copyright over peoples’ reviews. The FTC says to do this even if you’ve never tried to enforce it or have no intention of enforcing it. Search for words such as review, disparage, defame, feedback, comment and copyright.
Ask every buyer the same way
Send one review request to all buyers, with the same public link, whatever they thought of the order. Do not route unhappy buyers to a private form, and do not tie a discount or gift to a review on Google.
Write a neutral moderation policy
If you moderate reviews on your own site, use criteria for withholding reviews that are applied equally to all reviews submitted without regard to sentiment, and publish those reasons. Keep negative reviews that are on topic and honest.
Where Nation fits
Nation
Category: an AI store builder
Nation says one description of what you make builds the store, then agents handle orders, customers and delivery and run ads, content and social posts, with you approving the work. This page explains review law and does not describe any Nation feature.
Limits today
- Status: open: describe what you make in the app onboarding and the store builds itself.
- Pricing and fees: from $39 a month plus a 2% fee per sale, with a 14-day trial for $1.
- Shopper marketplace: no shopper marketplace has been announced.
- Track record: no independent reviews or public stores yet.
Nation publishes this page. It is general information about US review law, not legal advice.
Describe what you makeQuestions about the Consumer Review Fairness Act and review gating
What does the Consumer Review Fairness Act do?
The Consumer Review Fairness Act bans form contracts, such as online terms of sale, that restrict honest reviews, fine people for reviewing, or take the rights in their reviews. A banned clause is void from the inception of such contract, and offering it is unlawful even if the business never enforces it.
Can I put a no-negative-reviews clause in my terms of sale?
A no-negative-reviews clause in your terms of sale breaks the Consumer Review Fairness Act. The FTC gives the example of a business that includes a provision in its terms and conditions that prohibits or punishes negative reviews by customers. The clause cannot be enforced, and including it can lead to financial penalties, as well as a federal court order.
Can I remove a negative review from my own website?
You can remove a review from your own website for content reasons, not because it is negative. The CRFA allows removing a review that contains confidential or private information, is libelous, harassing, abusive, obscene, vulgar, sexually explicit, is unrelated to the company’s products or services, or is clearly false or misleading. The FTC's review rule also expects criteria applied equally to all reviews.
Is review gating illegal?
Review gating, asking only happy customers for public reviews, breaks Google's review policy, which bans merchants who Discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers. The FTC says its review rule does not contain a specific prohibition against such conduct, but this practice could violate the FTC Act. Ask every buyer the same way instead.
Does the Consumer Review Fairness Act apply to employees?
The Consumer Review Fairness Act does not cover staff. The FTC says it doesn’t apply to employment contracts or agreements with independent contractors. Other rules still apply to staff reviews: the FTC's review rule bars certain reviews and testimonials written by company insiders that fail to clearly and conspicuously disclose the giver’s material connection to the business.