Quick answer
You can sell fan art legally when the owner of the characters gives you permission, usually through a licence, because US copyright law gives the owner the exclusive right to prepare derivative works based upon the copyrighted work. Without permission, selling fan art is a risk: fair use is decided case by case, and character names and logos can also be trademarks. On Etsy, Sellers are responsible for ensuring they have all necessary rights to their content, and Etsy will remove material cited for alleged intellectual property infringement when provided with a report that complies with our policies.
Nation, an AI store builder, publishes this page. It is open: describe what you make in the app onboarding and the store builds itself, so it is not in the fee comparison. See where Nation fits.
Can you sell fan art? The short answer
Fan art is art based on characters, worlds or designs that someone else created. Under US copyright law, a drawing of an existing character is usually a derivative work, which the Copyright Act defines as a work based upon one or more preexisting works. Preparing derivative works and selling copies are both rights of the copyright owner.
So the honest answer is that selling fan art without permission is copyright infringement unless a defence such as fair use applies, and fair use is hard to rely on for a product sold for money. When an owner does not act against fan art, that is the owner's choice, not a legal right of the artist. The owner can still file a takedown report, send a demand letter or sue.
This page is general information about US federal law and platform policy, not legal advice. A trademark owner can sue in either state court or federal court, and rules vary by state and by country, so talk to a lawyer about a specific product or a letter you received.
Fan art copyright: what the owner controls
Copyright protects original creative works, including drawings, films, comics and games. The owner gets a set of exclusive rights. Three of them matter most when you sell fan art.
- The right to reproduce the copyrighted work in copies or phonorecords. Copying a still from a show or a panel from a comic falls here.
- The right to prepare derivative works based upon the copyrighted work. A new drawing of an existing character in your own style is a derivative work, because the definition covers any other form in which a work may be recast, transformed, or adapted.
- The right to distribute copies or phonorecords of the copyrighted work to the public by sale. Selling prints, stickers or shirts distributes copies.
Redrawing a character does not make it yours. The Copyright Office says you cannot claim copyright to another's work, no matter how much you change it, unless you have the owner's consent. Without permission, your own additions may not be protected either: copyright in a derivative work does not extend to any part of the work in which such material has been used unlawfully.
There is also no safe percentage. The Copyright Office states there are no legal rules permitting the use of a specific number of words, a certain number of musical notes, or percentage of a work. Changing a costume colour or a set number of details does not move a piece out of infringement.
The stakes are set by statute. The Copyright Office notes that an infringer may be liable for statutory damages up to $30,000 for each work infringed, and up to $150,000 for each work infringed if the infringement is willful.
Is it legal to sell fan art under fair use?
Fair use lets people use protected works without a licence in some cases. The Copyright Act names four factors, and Courts evaluate fair use claims on a case-by-case basis. Here is how each one tends to apply to fan art sold for money.
- Purpose and character of the use. Courts look at whether the use is of a commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes. Selling is commercial. Transformative uses, which add something new, with a further purpose or different character, and do not substitute for the original use of the work, weigh toward fair use. A parody that comments on the original can be transformative; a faithful portrait of a character usually is not.
- Nature of the original. The Copyright Office notes that using a more creative or imaginative work (such as a novel, movie, or song) is less likely to support a claim of a fair use. Characters from films, games and comics are highly creative works.
- Amount used. Courts look at how much was taken and how important it was. Even a small part can count: in some cases, using even a small amount of a copyrighted work was determined not to be fair because the selection was an important part. A character is often the heart of the work.
- Effect on the market. Courts consider whether the use is hurting the current market for the original work (for example, by displacing sales of the original). Fan merchandise can compete with official merchandise and with licences the owner could sell.
Put together, fan art sold as prints, stickers or apparel tends to weigh against fair use on several factors. Fair use is a defence you argue after a claim, and only a federal court can determine whether a particular use is, in fact, a fair use. The Copyright Office's own advice is that in cases of doubt, the Copyright Office recommends that permission be obtained.
Trademark: names, logos and the look of official merchandise
Copyright is only half of the question. Character names, titles and logos can also be trademarks for goods such as clothing, posters and toys.
The USPTO defines trademark infringement as the unauthorized use of a trademark or service mark on or in connection with goods in a way likely to cause confusion, deception, or mistake about the source of the goods. In court, the owner must show the use is likely to cause confusion in the minds of consumers about the source or sponsorship. A shirt with an official title logo, or a listing called "official" merchandise, invites exactly that claim.
A trademark owner can sue in either state court or federal court. If infringement is proven, remedies can include money, made up of defendant's profits, any damages sustained by the plaintiff, and the costs of the action, and an order for the destruction or forfeiture of infringing articles. Owners of famous marks can also claim dilution, asserting that it owns a famous mark and the use of your mark diminishes the strength or value.
- Leave official logos, title fonts and franchise names out of the artwork.
- Describe what the item is in the listing title, and avoid words such as "official" or "licensed" unless they are true.
- Do not copy the packaging, tags or layout of official products.
These steps lower the trademark risk. They do nothing about the copyright in the character itself.
Can you sell fan art on Etsy? How Etsy handles reports
Etsy does not decide whether fan art infringes. Its intellectual property policy says Etsy can't speak for rights owners, nor is Etsy in a position to offer legal advice or make legal determinations. What happens to a fan art listing depends on whether the owner reports it.
The listing goes up on your responsibility
Etsy's policy says Sellers are responsible for ensuring they have all necessary rights to their content and that they are not infringing anyone's rights.
A rights owner files a report
Owners report listings through the Etsy Reporting Portal. Etsy says it Etsy will remove material cited for alleged intellectual property infringement when provided with a report that complies with our policies. Etsy may give you a copy of the infringement report, including the name and email address of the reporting party, so you can see who complained.
You can file a counter notice in some cases
Etsy accepts counter notices for US-based copyright infringement reports only. The listing may be restored 10 business days after the counter notice is processed, unless the copyright owner files an action seeking a court order restraining the allegedly infringing party from relisting the items or a qualifying action with the Copyright Claims Board (CCB) and informs Etsy. File a counter notice only if you believe the work does not infringe.
Only the owner can withdraw the report
Etsy only accepts withdrawals of infringement reports directly from the intellectual property owner or authorized representative. If you reach an agreement with the owner, such as a licence, ask them to withdraw it.
Repeat reports can close the shop
Etsy terminates selling privileges of members who are subject to repeat or multiple notices of intellectual property infringement. Losing selling privileges affects the whole shop, including any original work sold in it.
How to sell fan art legally: lower-risk routes
The only route that removes the copyright question is permission. The others reduce risk or avoid the protected material altogether.
Get a licence from the owner
Some publishers, studios and game companies run licensing programs or official artist programs. A licence is a contract that says which characters, products, territories and dates you may use, and usually what royalty you pay. Get it in writing and keep a copy with your product records.
Sell where the owner allows fan merchandise
Some rights owners allow fan sales through their own marketplaces, convention rules or written fan content policies. Read the policy itself, not a summary, and follow its limits on products and quantities.
Use characters whose copyright has expired
For works created after January 1, 1978, copyright lasts the life of the author plus an additional 70 years. For a work made for hire, the term is 95 years from the year of its first publication or a term of 120 years from the year of its creation, whichever expires first. For works first published before 1978, the term will vary depending on several factors, so check the specific work. When an early version of a character enters the public domain, later versions, costumes and logos can still be protected by copyright and trademark.
Make work that comments on the original
Parody and commentary are the uses most likely to count as fair use, because they add something new. They are still judged case by case, so the risk stays with you.
Create original characters
Characters you design yourself are protected by your own copyright from the moment it is created and fixed in a tangible form. You can sell, license and register them, and no studio holds rights in them.
Checklist before you list character-based art
Run through these questions for each design. A no on any of the first three means the listing carries real legal risk.
- Do you have a written licence or a published fan content policy that covers this product?
- Is the artwork free of official logos, title lettering and trademarked names?
- Does the listing avoid words such as "official", "licensed" or the franchise name in the title?
- If you rely on fair use, does the piece comment on or transform the original, rather than just depict a character?
- Do you know what you will do if you receive a takedown notice or a demand letter?
If you receive a demand letter or a lawsuit, contact a lawyer before you reply. Rules differ by state and by country, and this page is general information, not legal advice.
Where Nation fits
Nation
Category: an AI store builder
Nation says one description of what you make builds the store, then agents handle orders, customers and delivery and run ads, content and social posts, with you approving the work. Nation does not give legal advice, and this page is general information.
Limits today
- Status: open: describe what you make in the app onboarding and the store builds itself.
- Pricing and fees: from $39 a month plus a 2% fee per sale, with a 14-day trial for $1.
- Shopper marketplace: no shopper marketplace has been announced.
- Track record: no independent reviews or public stores yet.
Nation publishes this page. Nation is not a law firm, and nothing on this page is legal advice.
Describe what you makeQuestions about selling fan art
Is it legal to sell fan art?
Selling fan art is legal when the owner of the characters gives you permission, such as a licence. Without permission, it usually infringes the owner's exclusive right to prepare derivative works based upon the copyrighted work. Fair use can apply in some cases, such as parody, but courts decide it case by case, and commercial sales weigh against it.
Can you sell fan art on Etsy?
You can list fan art on Etsy, but Etsy's policy says Sellers are responsible for ensuring they have all necessary rights to their content. Etsy does not judge each listing. It removes listings when a rights owner files a valid report, and it terminates selling privileges of members who are subject to repeat or multiple notices of intellectual property infringement. Licensed or original work avoids that risk.
Is fan art protected by copyright?
Fan art made without permission has weak copyright protection. Under the Copyright Act, copyright in a derivative work does not extend to any part of the work in which such material has been used unlawfully. Licensed fan art can carry copyright in the artist's own additions, such as the background, but the character itself stays with its owner.
How much do I have to change a character to sell it?
No amount of change makes another person's character safe to sell. The Copyright Office says there are no legal rules permitting the use of a specific number of words, a certain number of musical notes, or percentage of a work. A redrawn or restyled character is still a derivative work. Permission, expired copyright or original characters are the ways to remove the question.
What happens if I get caught selling fan art?
Selling fan art without permission can lead to a takedown on the platform, a demand letter or a lawsuit. For registered works, statutory damages can reach $30,000 for each work infringed, or $150,000 for each work infringed for willful infringement. Trademark remedies can include defendant's profits, any damages sustained by the plaintiff, and the costs of the action.