Skip to the answer

Loyalty program for small business: points, punch cards and tiers

By Nation 9 min read

Quick answer

A loyalty program for a small business rewards repeat customers with points, a digital punch card or tiers that unlock bigger perks. Shops that sell in person can run one in Square Loyalty, where customers earn by visits, amount spent, or items or categories purchased and enroll with their phone number. Shopify stores add a loyalty app such as Smile, which has a free plan for up to 200 monthly orders.

Nation, an AI store builder, publishes this page. It is not among the tools described. See where Nation fits.

How a loyalty program for a small business works

A loyalty program gives customers a reason to come back to you instead of the shop down the street. Each purchase or visit earns something, and once a customer has earned enough, they get a reward: a discount, a free item, free shipping or a better level of service.

For a small business, the program has to be simple enough that staff can explain it in one sentence at the till, and cheap enough that the rewards cost less than the extra sales they bring in. Most small shops pick one of three formats: points, a punch card or tiers. The software then does the counting, so nobody has to stamp paper cards or keep a spreadsheet of who bought what.

The two tools covered here are the ones many small shops already sell through. In Square Loyalty, customers can join right in the register, when submitting an invoice payment, or online when completing a purchase. Shopify stores add a loyalty app from the Shopify App Store, and can also use Shopify's own store credit as a reward.

Points, punch-card and tier programs compared

Each format suits a different kind of shop. The table shows how customers earn, what kind of business it fits and how it maps to Square and to a Shopify app.

Three customer loyalty program formats for a small shop
FormatHow customers earnFitsIn Square LoyaltyIn a Shopify app
Punch card (visits)One stamp or point per visit, whatever they spendCafes, bakeries, barbers, car washes: frequent visits at a similar priceA visit-based programCheck the app's earning rules; Smile lists 15+ ways to earn & redeem
Points (spend)Points per dollar spent, swapped for a rewardShops where the basket size varies a lot, and online storesA spend-based program; you can exclude items, an option only available for spend-based loyalty programsOn Smile, the free plan includes Points, rewards & referrals
Item or categoryPoints only on chosen productsShops that want to push one line, such as refills or a new rangeAn item-based or category-based programDepends on the app and plan
Tiers (VIP)Customers move up levels as they earn, and higher levels earn faster or get extra perksShops with a core of regulars who spend well above averageup to six tiers, including your core base tier, with progress on a rolling 12-month basisOn Smile, VIP tiers & Points expiry are listed under the Growth plan at $199 / month, includes 2,500 monthly orders, then $20 per additional 100 orders

Start with one format. A punch card is the easiest to explain; points are the most flexible; tiers only make sense once you already have regulars to sort into levels.

How to create a loyalty program, step by step

These steps apply whichever software you use. Settle the first three on paper before you open any app.

  1. Pick the behaviour you want more of

    Decide whether you want more visits, bigger baskets or more sales of one product line. Visits point to a punch card, basket size to points per dollar, and a product line to an item or category program.

  2. Set a reward you can afford

    Work out the cost of the reward as a share of what a customer spends to earn it. Keep it below your margin on those sales, and pick a reward customers notice, such as a free coffee or a set amount off.

  3. Decide whether points expire

    Expiry gives customers a reason to come back sooner and limits what you owe on old points. In Square you can expire points after a set number of months, and customers get an SMS notification 14 days before their points expire.

  4. Choose the software

    Use Square Loyalty if you sell through Square's point of sale, invoices or Square Online. Use a Shopify loyalty app if you sell through Shopify, and check that it also works with Shopify POS if you sell in person.

  5. Make sign-up take seconds

    In Square, customers enter their phone number at checkout. Online, put the sign-up on the account page and the order confirmation. Tell staff to offer it to every customer.

  6. Check the numbers after a few months

    Compare how often members come back and how much they spend with non-members, and count how many rewards were redeemed. If almost nobody reaches a reward, lower the threshold; if the rewards cost more than you expected, raise it.

Square Loyalty: setup, limits and cost

Square Loyalty is set up in Square Dashboard under Customers, then Loyalty. The enrollment screens then appear in the Square POS app, Square Terminal, or Square Register. Customers earn no matter how they pay, but to earn points they must provide the same phone number for each payment method used.

You can try it free for 30 days. After that you need a Square Loyalty subscription or a higher plan: Square's help center lists the feature for Square Loyalty subscribers and for Square Plus and Premium subscribers. Square Plus costs $49 a month per location and also includes text marketing: 500 texts are included per month per account, then pay 3¢ per text.

Square Loyalty settings and limits
SettingWhat Square allows
Ways to earnvisits, amount spent, or items or categories purchased
Rewards per programup to 15 rewards
Tiersup to six tiers, including your core base tier
Tier progressCounted on a rolling 12-month basis
Points expiryOptional; customers get an SMS notification 14 days before their points expire
Excluding itemsonly available for spend-based loyalty programs
Sign-upCustomers enter their phone number at the point of sale
Trialfree for 30 days

This page does not give a price for a Square Loyalty subscription on its own, so check the current price with Square before the trial ends.

Shopify loyalty program options: apps and store credit

A Shopify loyalty program usually runs through an app from the Shopify App Store, which tracks points and turns them into rewards. Smile is one such app; its plans, as listed on the Shopify App Store, are below.

Shopify also has store credit, and its help center lists issuing it as a reward or incentive, such as a loyalty or referral program. Customers can spend it only when signed in through customer accounts or using Shop Pay. For stores created on or after May 12, 2025, orders that include store credit as a payment method are charged third-party transaction fees on the order amount paid for using store credit. Shopify notes that the fee is waived on the Shopify Plus plan with Shopify Payments activated, so check how your app pays out rewards before you choose it.

Smile loyalty app plans on the Shopify App Store
PlanPrice and order limit
Freeup to 200 monthly orders
Essential$15 / month, up to 500 monthly orders
Standard$79 / month, up to 1,000 monthly orders
Growth$199 / month, includes 2,500 monthly orders, then $20 per additional 100 orders; adds VIP tiers & Points expiry
Paid plan trial14-day free trial

Smile prices its plans by monthly orders, so the cost rises as the shop grows. Compare the next plan up with what the program brings in before you upgrade.

Example: working out a reward that pays for itself

Example: a cafe with an average ticket of $5 runs a punch card where the tenth coffee is free. A customer spends $45 on nine coffees to earn one coffee worth $5 at the till. If the coffee costs the cafe $1.50 to make, the reward costs $1.50 against $45 of sales, about 3 percent.

Example: a gift shop gives 1 point per $1 spent and a $10 reward at 200 points. A customer spends $200 to earn $10 off, a 5 percent discount on what they spent. If the shop's margin is 50 percent, the reward costs a tenth of the margin on those sales.

In both examples the reward is small next to the spending it takes to earn it. That is the test for any program: the reward has to be worth chasing for the customer and still leave you a margin.

Common mistakes with a small business loyalty program

Most loyalty programs that fail do so for one of a few plain reasons.

  • A reward so far away that customers forget about it. If most customers would need a year to reach it, lower the threshold.
  • Too many rules. One way to earn and one or two rewards are easier to explain than a long menu.
  • Staff who do not mention it. Enrollment happens at the till or at checkout; if nobody offers it, nobody joins.
  • Paying for features you do not use. Tiers and integrations often sit on higher plans, as VIP tiers do on Smile's Growth plan; start on the free or entry plan.
  • Never checking the results. Compare members with non-members every few months and change the reward if it is not working.

Where Nation fits

Nation

Category: an AI store builder

Publisher

Nation says one description of what you make builds the store, then agents handle orders, customers and delivery and run ads, content and social posts, with you approving the work. Plans start at $39 a month plus a 2% fee on each sale, with a 14-day trial for $1.

Limits today

  • Status: open: describe what you make in the app onboarding and the store builds itself.
  • Pricing and fees: from $39 a month plus a 2% fee per sale, with a 14-day trial for $1.
  • Shopper marketplace: no shopper marketplace has been announced.
  • Track record: no independent reviews or public stores yet.

Nation publishes this page.

Describe what you make

Questions about loyalty programs for small businesses

What is the best loyalty program for a small business?

The best loyalty program for a small business is the one customers understand at once and the shop can afford. A punch card suits frequent visits at a similar price, points per dollar suit varied baskets, and tiers suit shops with many regulars. Run it in the software you already sell through.

How do I create a customer loyalty program?

To create a customer loyalty program, choose what to reward (visits, spend or certain products), set a reward that costs less than your margin on the sales needed to earn it, and decide whether points expire. Then set it up in your point of sale or store software and ask every customer to join.

How much does Square Loyalty cost?

Square Loyalty can be tried free for 30 days. After the trial it needs a Square Loyalty subscription or a higher plan: Square's help center lists it for Square Plus and Premium subscribers, and Square Plus costs $49 a month per location. Check the current Square Loyalty price with Square before the trial ends.

Does Shopify have a loyalty program?

A Shopify loyalty program usually runs through an app from the Shopify App Store. Smile, one such app, has a free plan for up to 200 monthly orders and paid plans from $15 / month, up to 500 monthly orders. Shopify's help center also lists store credit as a reward or incentive, such as a loyalty or referral program.

Should loyalty points expire?

Loyalty points that expire give customers a reason to return sooner and stop old points building up as a cost you still owe. The trade-off is that some customers dislike losing points. Square lets you expire points after a set number of months and sends customers an SMS notification 14 days before their points expire.

Describe what you make

Nation is an AI store builder. It is open: describe what you make in the app onboarding and the store builds itself. Describe what you make and continue in the app.