Skip to the answer

Pigment vs dye ink: what the difference means for art prints

By Nation 10 min read

Quick answer

Pigment ink carries solid colour particles that stay put once dry, so prints resist water and hold up better against fading. Dye ink is colour dissolved in liquid that soaks into the paper, so it can run if the print gets wet and relies more on the paper to resist fading. For art prints, check the maker's permanence data for your exact ink and paper, and for stickers that get wet, add a laminate layer over the ink.

Nation, an AI store builder, publishes this page. It is open: describe what you make in the app onboarding and the store builds itself, so it does not sell printers, ink or prints. See where Nation fits.

Pigment vs dye ink: the difference

Pigment ink and dye ink both come out of an inkjet printer as tiny drops. The difference is what carries the colour. In dye ink the colour is dissolved in the liquid, the way sugar dissolves in water. In pigment ink the colour is made of solid particles held in the liquid.

That changes where the colour ends up. Epson's own technical brief puts it this way: with dye ink, dye molecules dissolve again and move if the paper gets wet, causing smearing. With pigment ink, pigment particles do not dissolve when wet and do not smear. Dye ink also behaves differently by paper: Epson describes conventional dye inks as water-resistant on many glossy photo papers but not on matte papers.

Both kinds are sold for photo printing. Epson's SureColor P700 uses UltraChrome PRO10, 10-color archival pigment ink, while Epson describes the ink for its Expression Photo HD XP-15000 as 6-color Claria Photo HD dye-based ink. Canon lists its imagePROGRAF PRO-300 as using pigment-based LUCIA PRO ink.

Pigment ink vs dye ink at a glance
Pigment inkDye ink
What carries the colourSolid particles held in the liquidColour dissolved in the liquid
When the print gets wetParticles do not dissolve, so the print does not smearDye can dissolve again and move, so the print can smear
Water resistance by paperwater-resistant on all supported media, including plain paperwater-resistant on many glossy photo papers but not on matte papers
Fade resistanceRated by makers for named ink and paper combinationsdye inks depend on special paper to resist fading
Example printersEpson SureColor P700 and P900, Canon imagePROGRAF PRO-300Epson Expression Photo HD XP-15000

Water and fade resistance for prints you sell

A buyer will not keep your print in a lab. Art prints get handled, framed in rooms with daylight, and sometimes splashed. Stickers go on water bottles and laptops. The two things that decide how long the colour lasts are water and light, and pigment and dye ink differ on both.

Water is the simpler one. Because dye can dissolve again, a dye print can smear when it gets wet. Pigment particles stay put once they dry. Paper changes the picture for dye ink: Epson's brief rates conventional dye inks as water-resistant on many glossy photo papers but not on matte papers, while it rates its pigment ink as water-resistant on all supported media, including plain paper.

Fading is harder to compare, because it depends on the whole combination: ink, paper, light, air and frame. Epson's product page for its pigment printers says the ink is expected to give WIR display permanence ratings of up to 200 years for color and 400 years for black-and-white. The footnote that goes with it matters just as much: the ratings come from accelerated testing of prints on specified media, displayed indoors, under glass, and Epson does not guarantee longevity of prints. For maximum print life, Epson's advice is to display prints under glass or UV-absorbing acrylic and protect them from prolonged high humidity.

So treat a permanence number as a result for one paper under glass, not as a promise for every print. If you sell unframed prints, tell buyers how to display them, and pass on the maker's care advice in your listing.

What lightfastness data and ISO tests measure

Fade ratings in years come from accelerated tests: the print gets far more exposure than it would on a wall, and the colour change is measured. Epson's ratings, for example, are based on accelerated testing of prints on specified media, displayed indoors, under glass. ISO, the international standards body, publishes test methods for image permanence. Each method measures one cause of fading.

ISO image permanence test methods
What it testsStandardNote for inkjet prints
Fading from indoor lightISO 18937-1:2023, methods for measuring indoor light stability of photographic printsresults for one printer, settings, colorant and media combination may not apply to another
Fading from ozone in the airISO 18941:2020, test method for ozone gas fading stability of colour reflection prints; it uses increased levels of ozone to achieve an accelerated testCovers digitally printed hardcopy images and traditional analogue photographic colour prints
Dark storage and colour stability of photographic printsISO 18909:2022, methods for measuring image stability of processed photographic colour films and paper prints, which measures long-term dark storage stability and colour stability under set illuminants, temperatures and humiditiesnot verified for ink jet; digitally printed prints are referred to ISO 18941 and others for dark stability and the ISO 18937 series for light stability

Two practical points follow. First, the photographic print standard is written for traditional prints, so an inkjet maker citing it should explain which test it actually ran. Second, a rating only holds for the printer, ink and paper it was tested with. If you change paper, the published number no longer describes your print.

Archival papers and printable sticker stock

Paper decides as much about a print's life as the ink. Epson, for example, describes its Hot Press Natural fine art paper as acid free, 100% cotton rag with a natural smooth finish. It lists $33.00 for 25 sheets of 8.5 x 11 in and $91.00 for 25 sheets of 13 x 19 in on its US store. Canon lists Premium Fine Art Smooth and Premium Fine Art Rough among the fine art media for the PRO-300, and the printer takes paper up to approx. 380 gsm, 0.1 to 0.6 mm through the manual feed slot.

Use the paper maker's own printer profile for the paper you choose, and match the black ink to the surface: photo black for glossy papers, matte black for matte papers. The P700 has dedicated nozzles for both photo black and matte black ink, with no switching.

Stickers are a different job. Cricut's printable sticker paper is for inkjet printers only; laser printers may damage the material or printer. For stickers that will get wet, Cricut's Printable Waterproof Sticker Set uses a printable vinyl sheet and a laminating sheet, so the laminate protects the ink. Cricut's own FAQ notes that colors may fade because ink formulations vary; Cricut recommends a UV resistant ink. It also recommends that stickered items be washed by hand: handwash; dishwasher heat and detergents may reduce the life of the item.

  • For art prints: an acid free cotton or fine art paper with a published profile for your printer.
  • For indoor stickers and labels: inkjet printable sticker paper, cut on a Print Then Cut machine.
  • For water bottles and outdoor use: a printable vinyl with a laminate layer on top, whatever ink you use.

Printer for art prints: print width and ink

The two specs that shape what you can sell are the widest sheet the printer takes and the ink it uses. Width sets your largest print size. Ink type sets the water and fade behaviour described above. The table lists both for four desktop photo printers, read on the makers' own pages on the date at the foot of this page. It is a spec list, not a ranking.

Desktop photo printer specs from the makers' pages
PrinterInkMaximum width or paper sizeCartridge size and price
Epson SureColor P700UltraChrome PRO10, 10-color archival pigment ink13 inches25 mL at $44.00 each, 10 colours
Epson SureColor P900UltraChrome PRO10, 10-color archival pigment ink17 inches50 mL at $51.00 each
Canon imagePROGRAF PRO-300pigment-based LUCIA PRO ink13 x 19 in (A3+), and custom sizes up to 13 x 39 in14.4 mL per ink, 10 inks
Epson Expression Photo HD XP-150006-color Claria Photo HD dye-based inkup to 13 inchesSee Epson's ink finder

Printer prices on the makers' stores move with sales. On the fetch date Epson listed the P700 at $849.00 list, $699.00 after an 18% sale discount and the P900 at $1,349.00 list, $1,145.00 after a 15% sale discount.

How to work out ink and paper cost per print

Printer makers publish cartridge sizes and prices, but the pages above do not state how much ink one print uses. That depends on the image, the paper and the print settings. You can measure it yourself.

  1. Find the cost per millilitre

    Divide the cartridge price by its size. For the P700 that is $44.00 divided by 25 mL. Epson lists every 770 colour at the same price, so one figure covers the set.

  2. Measure ink used on a test batch

    Note the ink levels the printer driver reports, print a batch of the same image at your selling size, and note the levels again. Divide the change by the number of prints. A batch gives a steadier figure than one print.

  3. Add the paper

    Divide the pack price by the sheet count. Epson lists $33.00 for 25 sheets of 8.5 x 11 in, so one letter sheet is that price divided by the count. Add the sheets you lose to test prints and misfeeds.

  4. Add cleaning and spoilage

    Printers also use ink on head cleaning. Add a margin for that and for spoiled sheets, then compare the total with a print lab's quote for the same size and paper.

Printing at home gives you control over colour and lets you print one copy at a time. It also means buying the printer, keeping spare cartridges and storing paper. A print lab or print-on-demand service spreads those costs over many customers.

  • You sell sizes wider than 17 inches, the widest desktop printer in the table above.
  • You sell a few prints a month: cartridges and paper packs cost the same whether you use them or not.
  • You want a paper or finish your printer cannot handle, such as canvas or metal.
  • You want orders printed and shipped without handling them: a print-on-demand service does both.
  • You print stickers in volume: for its waterproof sticker set, Cricut advises you to load and print only one sticker sheet at a time.

Whichever route you take, ask the lab which ink and paper it uses, and pass that on to buyers. It is the information a permanence rating depends on.

Where Nation fits

Nation

Category: an AI store builder

Publisher

Nation says one description of what you make builds the store, then agents handle orders, customers and delivery and run ads, content and social posts, with you approving the work. It does not make printers, ink or prints.

Limits today

  • Status: open: describe what you make in the app onboarding and the store builds itself.
  • Pricing and fees: from $39 a month plus a 2% fee per sale, with a 14-day trial for $1.
  • Shopper marketplace: no shopper marketplace has been announced.
  • Track record: no independent reviews or public stores yet.

Nation publishes this page. No printer, ink or paper maker paid to be named on it.

Describe what you make

Questions about pigment and dye ink

Is pigment ink better than dye ink for art prints?

Pigment ink suits art prints that buyers will handle and frame, because pigment particles do not dissolve when wet and makers publish long display ratings for pigment sets on named papers. Dye ink relies more on special paper to resist fading and can run on matte paper. Check the rating for your exact ink and paper.

Pigment ink vs dye ink: which is waterproof?

Pigment ink resists water better than dye ink: Epson describes pigment particles as not dissolving or smearing once dry. Dye ink is water resistant on many glossy photo papers but not on matte papers. Neither ink makes paper waterproof, so stickers for water bottles still need a laminate layer on top.

Which ink should I use for printable stickers?

Printable sticker paper from Cricut is made for inkjet printers only, so either pigment or dye inkjet ink can be used on it. For stickers that get wet, Cricut's waterproof set adds a laminating sheet over the print. Cricut notes that some colour fading can still happen and recommends a UV resistant ink.

What should I look for in a printer for art prints?

A printer for art prints is chosen on maximum paper width, ink type and the papers it supports. Width sets your largest sale size. Pigment ink sets water and fade behaviour. Supported paper thickness decides whether heavy fine art paper feeds. Ink cartridge size and price set your running cost per print.

What do lightfastness ratings in years mean?

Lightfastness ratings in years come from accelerated tests that expose a print to far more light than a wall would. Epson's ratings assume specified media, indoor display and glass, and Epson does not guarantee print longevity. A rating applies only to the printer, ink and paper combination that was tested.

Describe what you make

Nation is an AI store builder. It is open: describe what you make in the app onboarding and the store builds itself. Describe what you make and continue in the app.