Quick answer
An Etsy custom order starts when a buyer sends a request through the Request Custom Order button, which you turn on in Shop Manager settings. You agree the details and price in Etsy Messages, then create a private listing from that thread that only that buyer can purchase. For items you already make with set options, use personalization fields or variations on a normal listing instead.
Nation, an AI store builder, publishes this page. It is not part of any comparison here. See where Nation fits.
What an Etsy custom order is
An Etsy custom order is a one-off item you make to a single buyer's brief. The buyer asks for it through your shop, you agree what you will make and what it costs in Etsy Messages, and you send them a private listing to pay for. Etsy calls this a custom listing. Sellers often call it a reserved listing, because nobody else can buy it.
Etsy gives you three ways to sell made-to-order work, and each one fits a different kind of request. The table sets them side by side so you can pick the right tool before you build anything.
Etsy's own rule of thumb: use personalization when The input doesn’t impact your product inventory levels, use variations when each option affects inventory, price or SKU, and use a custom listing when the item is for one particular buyer only.
How to turn on custom order requests
You can add custom order requests once your shop is open to the public, and the setting can only be enabled on Etsy.com, not in the Seller app.
Open Shop Manager settings
On Etsy.com, go to Shop Manager, then Settings, then Options.
Enable the setting
Under Custom order requests, select Enabled, then select Save.
Check your shop homepage
Once it is on, Etsy says: A Request Custom Order button will appear on your shop homepage. Buyers who select it can describe what they want and, if they have one, the date they need it by.
How to create a custom order on Etsy
Every custom listing is built from a conversation, so the quote happens in Etsy Messages before any listing exists. A new request arrives in your Custom Requests folder; a request inside an existing thread lands in your Inbox.
Read the request and ask what is missing
Reply in the same thread with your questions: size, materials, colors, wording, deadline and delivery address country. Keep the whole agreement in Etsy Messages so it is on record if anything goes wrong later.
Quote a price and a timeline
Price the work, the materials and the shipping, and remember that Etsy takes its 6.5% transaction fee on the sale, plus payment processing (3% + $0.25 for a US shop paid to a US bank account). Give a realistic ship date that fits within your processing time.
Create the private listing from the thread
When the buyer agrees, make a custom, private listing directly from the original Custom Request Message thread. If the buyer wrote to you through a regular message instead of the request button, open that message and select Create custom order, fill in the required details and choose Send private listing.
Set shipping and processing
Choose a fixed-price shipping profile, because it is not possible to choose a calculated shipping profile for custom orders. Set a processing time that covers the making time; the longest Etsy allows on a custom order is 6-8 weeks.
Publish and wait for payment
Once you publish, Etsy sends the buyer an email with a button to purchase the listing. Start the work after the order is paid, unless you have agreed something different with the buyer in Messages.
Etsy private listings: who sees them and what they cost
A private listing is the listing Etsy creates for a custom order. It won't appear in your public shop or in search, so other buyers cannot purchase it. In your Listings page They’ll be labeled Private. After it sells, it will appear on your public Sold Items page with your other sold listings.
A private listing pays the same fees as other listings, with one difference in timing: you will only be charged the listing fee when the private listing is sold. For a US seller the listing fee is $0.20 per listing, and the sale also pays the 6.5% transaction fee and payment processing (3% + $0.25 for a US shop paid to a US bank account). Build those fees into the quote rather than adding them later.
Example: you quote $120 for a custom pet portrait with free shipping. Etsy's listing, transaction and processing fees all come out of that $120, so price the portrait so the amount left after fees still covers your time and materials. The full fee breakdown is in the Etsy fees guide.
- Private listings cannot be digital: Private listings cannot be created for digital items. For a custom digital file, Etsy points sellers to made-to-order digital listings instead.
- Calculated shipping is not available on a custom order, so set a flat shipping price you have checked against the carrier's rates.
- If the buyer changes the brief after you publish, agree the change in Messages and send a new private listing rather than editing the price quietly.
Etsy personalization: the Custom options fields
Personalization is for items you already make where each buyer adds their own detail, such as a name to engrave or a message on a card. Etsy calls these Custom options fields. You add them under Item options when you create or edit a listing, and you can add up to 5 fields per listing. Each field can be set as required or optional with the This field is required checkbox.
There are three field types: a text box for names, dates and messages; a list of options for choices like fonts or thread colors; and a file upload for photos, logos or artwork. The buyer's answers appear on your Orders page.
Add-on pricing lets you charge for a personalization, such as an embroidered name. It is only supported for optional, text-based Custom options fields, and each add-on price must be between $0.20 USD and $500 USD equivalent. When a buyer selects that field, the add-on is added to the item price automatically. Etsy suggests this over a variation when the only thing you charge more for is the text.
For personalized items such as engraved or monogrammed products, your primary image must show a finished, personalized item similar to the final product. Do not use personalization fields to collect a phone number; for that, Etsy says to contact them via Messages.
How to add variations on Etsy, and how to price them
Variations are set options on a normal listing, such as size, color or material. You can add variations for up to 3 item attributes: open the listing, go to Item options, select Add variation, pick from the list, and turn on price, quantity, processing profile or SKU if they change by option. To offer an option Etsy does not list, choose Create your own, but buyers won’t be able to filter their Etsy search results based on custom variations.
Pricing a variation trips up many sellers. The price you enter for each option is the total price for each version of the item, not an additional cost. Example: a small mug is $18 and a large one is $22, so you enter $22 for the large option, not $4.
Variations also let you set a different processing profile per option, which helps when one size is made to order and another ships from stock.
- Listings with three variation types can have up to 2,500 option combinations.
- Listings with one or two variation types can have up to 4,900 option combinations.
- You can set your own price, SKU or quantity for up to 400 option combinations.
- Variations are not currently supported for digital item listings.
Processing times for made-to-order items
For custom and personalized work, the processing time will include the amount of time it takes to create the custom item. Processing time starts the day after your item is purchased, and it sets the ship by date you commit to. It also controls when the buyer can open a case about an order and when they can leave a review, so a realistic number protects you twice.
Mark made-to-order listings as Made to order in their processing profile and give them their own profile, separate from ready-to-ship stock. On a private custom listing the ceiling is 6-8 weeks. If a piece runs late, you can edit the ship by date once, before the original “ship by” date has passed, and it can be extended up to 21 days. Agree the new date with the buyer in Messages first.
Returns and Purchase Protection on custom and personalized items
Returns on custom work follow your own return policy: Sellers aren’t required to accept returns, exchanges, or provide a refund unless stated in the return policy on their listing. Outside the EU, you must set a return policy whenever you edit or create a new listing for a physical item, even if that policy is no returns. Some sellers shipping to the EU must offer a minimum 14-day return policy on orders that ship to those countries.
If buyers can buy an item as-is or customized, Etsy suggests saying in your shop FAQ, under the topic Custom and personalized orders, that personalized orders cannot be returned. You can also edit your Messages to Buyers so the receipt tells shoppers you do not accept returns for customized or personalized items.
Etsy Purchase Protection for sellers works through eligibility rules. On an eligible order Etsy will cover up to $250 of a refund, and any remaining amount will be charged to the seller. Two rules matter most for made-to-order work: the order must be shipped within your stated processing time, and the item received must be one that matches the photos and description on your listing. You also need to reply to a buyer's Help with Order message within 48 hours. Etsy lists this case as not covered: The item doesn’t match the listing description. Write the agreed details into the private listing itself.
Where Nation fits
Nation
Category: an AI store builder
Nation says one description of what you make builds the store, then agents handle orders, customers and delivery and run ads, content and social posts, with you approving the work. Plans start at $39 a month plus a 2% fee on each sale, with a 14-day trial for $1.
Limits today
- Status: open: describe what you make in the app onboarding and the store builds itself.
- Pricing and fees: from $39 a month plus a 2% fee per sale, with a 14-day trial for $1.
- Shopper marketplace: no shopper marketplace has been announced.
- Track record: no independent reviews or public stores yet.
Nation publishes this page.
Describe what you makeQuestions about Etsy custom orders
How do I make a custom order on Etsy?
To make a custom order on Etsy, turn on custom order requests in Shop Manager under Settings and Options. When a buyer sends a request, agree the details and price in Messages, then create a private listing from that thread. Once you publish it, Etsy emails the buyer an email with a button to purchase the listing.
How do I make a private listing on Etsy?
A private listing on Etsy is made from a conversation with one buyer. Open the Custom Request message or a regular message from that buyer and select Create custom order, fill in the details and send the private listing. It won't appear in your public shop or in search, and Private listings cannot be created for digital items.
What is an Etsy reserved listing?
An Etsy reserved listing is the name sellers use for a listing set aside for one buyer. On Etsy today that is a private custom listing, created from a Messages thread. It won't appear in your public shop or in search, so only the buyer it was made for can purchase it. After it sells, it will appear on your public Sold Items page.
Should I use Etsy personalization or variations?
Etsy personalization fits details a buyer types or uploads, such as a name or a photo, when The input doesn’t impact your product inventory levels. Variations fit set options like size or color that change price, stock or SKU. You can add up to 5 fields per listing of personalization and variations for up to 3 item attributes.
Do I have to accept returns on Etsy custom orders?
Returns on Etsy custom orders depend on your own return policy. Etsy's rule: Sellers aren’t required to accept returns, exchanges, or provide a refund unless stated in the return policy on their listing. Say in your shop FAQ that personalized orders cannot be returned. Etsy Purchase Protection still needs the order shipped within your stated processing time and an item that matches the photos and description on your listing.